Ready to raise a glass and toast to the vibrant nightlife of St. Augustine? Look no further, as we’ve compiled a tantalizing list of the top 10 bars and pubs in this captivating city. From historic and charming to trendy and lively, these establishments cater to all tastes and will surely provide a memorable experience. So whether you’re a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor wanting to explore the best of St. Augustine’s bar scene, join us on a journey through this delightful selection. Cheers to that!

A Toast to St. Augustine: The Top 10 Bars and Pubs in the City

St. Augustine, known for its rich history and charming atmosphere, offers a vibrant nightlife scene with a variety of bars and pubs to suit every taste. Whether you’re looking for a laid-back tavern or a lively spot with live music, St. Augustine has it all. In this article, we’ll explore the top 10 bars and pubs in the city, highlighting their unique features and what makes them stand out.

1. The Milltop Tavern

– Overview

Located in the heart of historic St. Augustine, The Milltop Tavern is a beloved local institution. Established in 1983, this cozy pub has become a favorite hangout spot for both locals and tourists alike. With its warm and welcoming atmosphere, The Milltop Tavern offers a unique blend of history and entertainment.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

Stepping into The Milltop Tavern feels like stepping back in time. Its rustic decor and exposed brick walls create an intimate and nostalgic atmosphere. The outdoor patio, adorned with string lights and surrounded by lush greenery, provides the perfect setting for a relaxed evening with friends. Whether you choose to sit indoors or outdoors, you’re guaranteed a friendly and lively atmosphere.

– Menu and Drinks

The Milltop Tavern offers a mouthwatering menu that showcases classic pub fare with a twist. From juicy burgers to crispy chicken wings, there’s something for everyone. Don’t forget to pair your meal with one of their craft beers or signature cocktails. The bar boasts an impressive selection of local and international brews, ensuring there’s a drink to satisfy every palate.

– Events and Entertainment

One of the highlights of The Milltop Tavern is its live entertainment. From talented local musicians to crowd-pleasing karaoke nights, there’s never a dull moment at this pub. Whether you’re in the mood for some foot-tapping tunes or just want to unwind with a cold drink, The Milltop Tavern is the place to be.

2. Scarlett O’Hara’s

– Overview

For a taste of the South with a lively twist, look no further than Scarlett O’Hara’s. Located in the heart of downtown St. Augustine, this bar and restaurant combine classic Southern charm with a vibrant nightlife.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

Step into Scarlett O’Hara’s and be transported to a bygone era. The bar’s elegant decor, complete with velvet drapes and chandeliers, sets the stage for a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere. Whether you choose to sit at the bar or in one of the cozy booths, you’ll feel like a Southern belle or gentleman.

– Menu and Drinks

Scarlett O’Hara’s menu is a delightful blend of Southern and American cuisine. From mouthwatering shrimp and grits to delectable fried green tomatoes, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. Pair your meal with one of their carefully curated craft beers or indulge in a specialty cocktail. With a wide selection of drinks to choose from, Scarlett O’Hara’s ensures a memorable dining experience.

– Live Music

To enhance your evening, Scarlett O’Hara’s features live music performances by talented local musicians. Immerse yourself in the soothing melodies or get your feet tapping to upbeat tunes. The bar’s cozy atmosphere combined with live music creates the perfect ambiance for a night out on the town.

3. Prohibition Kitchen

– Overview

Prohibition Kitchen is a vibrant gastropub that pays homage to the days of prohibition. Located in historic downtown St. Augustine, this unique establishment offers an unparalleled experience for food and drink enthusiasts.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

Upon entering Prohibition Kitchen, you’re instantly transported to the era of speakeasies and clandestine gatherings. The dimly lit space, exposed brick walls, and vintage decor create an atmosphere of mystery and excitement. The prohibition-themed artwork further adds to the charm. Whether you’re sitting at the bar or in one of the cozy booths, you’ll feel like you’ve stepped into a hidden gem.

– Menu and Drinks

Prohibition Kitchen serves up a fusion of American comfort food with a modern twist. From hearty burgers to house-smoked barbecue, their menu is a food lover’s dream come true. Complement your meal with a craft cocktail that showcases the artistry and creativity of the bartenders. With a focus on fresh ingredients and innovative flavors, Prohibition Kitchen takes the culinary experience to a whole new level.

– Craft Cocktails

One highlight of Prohibition Kitchen is its extensive selection of craft cocktails. The bartenders are skilled in the art of mixology, creating masterful concoctions that delight the senses. Whether you prefer a classic old-fashioned or are willing to try something more adventurous, Prohibition Kitchen has a cocktail for every palate. Sit back, savor the flavors, and let the expertly crafted drinks transport you to the days of prohibition.

4. The Ice Plant

– Overview

Nestled in a historic ice plant building, The Ice Plant is a must-visit destination for cocktail enthusiasts and history buffs alike. This bar and restaurant take pride in their handcrafted cocktails and unique distillery process.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

The Ice Plant’s atmosphere is a perfect blend of industrial chic and historic charm. The original machinery and artifacts from the ice plant era add a touch of authenticity and intrigue. The bar’s spacious and open layout allows for both intimate conversations and larger gatherings. Whether you’re seated at the bar or in one of the comfortable booths, you’ll be surrounded by a captivating ambiance.

– Menu and Drinks

The Ice Plant offers a carefully curated menu that showcases their commitment to quality and craftsmanship. Their culinary creations, ranging from small plates to seasonal specials, are made with locally sourced ingredients. But the true highlight of The Ice Plant is its handcrafted cocktails. Each drink is meticulously prepared using their own in-house distilled spirits, ensuring a one-of-a-kind experience for every guest.

– Distillery Tour

For those interested in the distillation process, The Ice Plant offers guided tours of their on-site distillery. Learn about the history of the ice plant and the art of craft distilling while gaining insight into their unique methods. The tour culminates with a tasting, allowing visitors to savor the flavors and appreciate the skill that goes into each bottle.

5. Dos Gatos

– Overview

Dos Gatos is a hidden gem in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district. This speakeasy-style bar offers an intimate setting and expertly crafted cocktails, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

As you make your way down the unassuming alley, you’ll stumble upon the entrance to Dos Gatos. Stepping inside, you’ll be transported to a world of sophistication and style. The dimly lit space, plush seating, and vintage decor create an atmosphere reminiscent of the clandestine bars of the past. Whether you’re looking for a romantic evening or a cozy gathering with friends, Dos Gatos sets the stage for a memorable night.

– Menu and Drinks

Dos Gatos takes pride in its extensive selection of handcrafted cocktails. The expert mixologists behind the bar are passionate about their craft, constantly pushing the boundaries of flavor and presentation. From classic cocktails to innovative creations, every drink is a work of art. While enjoying your cocktail, peruse the menu of small plates and snacks that perfectly complement the libations.

– Speakeasy Vibe

What sets Dos Gatos apart is its commitment to the speakeasy vibe. The bar exudes an air of exclusivity, making guests feel like they’re part of a secret society. The attentive and knowledgeable staff adds to the mystique, ensuring a personalized experience for every guest. Prepare to be transported back in time as you sip on expertly crafted cocktails in the cozy confines of Dos Gatos.

6. Odd Birds

– Overview

For a truly unique bar experience, head to Odd Birds. Nestled in St. Augustine’s historic district, this hidden gem offers an eclectic menu and creative mixologist creations that cater to the adventurous palate.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

As you step into Odd Birds, you’ll be greeted by a quirky and whimsical atmosphere. The vibrant colors, eclectic decor, and comfortable seating create an ambiance that encourages exploration and discovery. Whether you’re sitting at the bar or lounging in one of the cozy corners, you’ll feel like you’ve stumbled upon a secret haven of creativity.

– Menu and Drinks

Odd Birds aims to surprise and delight with its innovative menu. Their small plates and shared dishes showcase a fusion of international flavors, highlighting the culinary expertise of the kitchen. Complementing the food is a selection of expertly crafted cocktails that push the boundaries of mixology. Each drink is a balance of unique flavors and unexpected combinations, reflecting the creativity and skill of the mixologists.

– Mixologist Creations

The mixologists at Odd Birds are true artists, constantly experimenting and pushing the limits of flavor and presentation. Their creations go beyond the traditional cocktails, incorporating unexpected ingredients and techniques. Whether you’re in the mood for a smoky mezcal concoction or a tangy tiki-inspired drink, Odd Birds guarantees a unique and unforgettable drinking experience.

7. The Tini Martini Bar

– Overview

Located within the Casablanca Inn, The Tini Martini Bar offers a sophisticated and glamorous experience. This intimate bar showcases an impressive selection of martinis, making it a must-visit for martini enthusiasts.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

The Tini Martini Bar exudes elegance and refinement. Its chic decor, low lighting, and cozy seating create an intimate and romantic atmosphere. The bar’s location within the Casablanca Inn adds a touch of old-world charm, transporting guests to a bygone era of luxury. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a place to unwind, The Tini Martini Bar provides a sophisticated setting.

– Menu and Drinks

As the name suggests, The Tini Martini Bar specializes in martinis. Their extensive menu features classic martinis as well as innovative variations that showcase the talents of the mixologists. Whether you prefer a dry and classic martini or a fruity and exotic twist, The Tini Martini Bar has a martini to suit every taste. Accompany your martini with one of their delectable small plates for a complete gourmet experience.

– Martini Varieties

The Tini Martini Bar takes pride in its diverse selection of martinis. From dirty martinis to dessert-inspired creations, there’s a martini for every preference. The bartenders are skilled in the art of mixology, ensuring each martini is perfectly balanced and presented with flair. Whether you’re a martini connoisseur or a curious beginner, The Tini Martini Bar guarantees an exceptional martini experience.

8. Stogies Jazz Club and Listening Room

– Overview

If you’re a jazz enthusiast looking for a cozy spot to enjoy live music, look no further than Stogies Jazz Club and Listening Room. Combining smooth jazz and a relaxed ambiance, this bar offers an unforgettable experience for music lovers.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

Stepping into Stogies Jazz Club and Listening Room feels like entering a hidden jazz club from the golden age of music. The intimate space, dim lighting, and comfortable seating create an atmosphere that is both inviting and nostalgic. The walls adorned with jazz memorabilia transport guests back in time, adding to the allure of this hidden gem.

– Menu and Drinks

While the focus at Stogies Jazz Club and Listening Room is primarily on the music, the bar also offers a selection of wine, craft beers, and cigars to complement the experience. Sip on a glass of fine wine or enjoy a smooth craft beer as you immerse yourself in the soothing melodies. If you’re a cigar aficionado, Stogies offers a variety of premium cigars to enhance your evening.

– Live Jazz Performances

The highlight of Stogies Jazz Club and Listening Room is undoubtedly the live jazz performances. Talented musicians take the stage, enchanting the audience with their melodious tunes. From smooth jazz to upbeat melodies, the music fills the room and transports guests to a world of rhythm and soul. Sit back, relax, and let the music wash over you at this hidden jazz haven.

9. Panama Hattie’s

– Overview

For a bar with stunning waterfront views and a laid-back atmosphere, Panama Hattie’s is the perfect choice. This beachfront establishment offers a mix of tropical cocktails and delicious cuisine, making it a popular spot for locals and tourists alike.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

Panama Hattie’s boasts a casual and relaxed atmosphere that perfectly suits its waterfront location. The open-air seating provides panoramic views of the water, creating a tranquil and idyllic setting. Whether you choose to sit at the bar or on the patio, you’ll be treated to gentle sea breezes and captivating sunsets. The friendly staff and welcoming vibe ensure a memorable experience for all.

– Menu and Drinks

The menu at Panama Hattie’s showcases a fusion of Caribbean and American flavors. From fresh seafood to tropical-inspired dishes, every bite is a burst of flavor. Complementing the cuisine is a selection of refreshing cocktails that transport you to a beachside paradise. Sip on a fruity daiquiri or indulge in a piña colada while enjoying the stunning views. Panama Hattie’s aims to create a culinary experience that captures the essence of the tropics.

– Waterfront Views

What sets Panama Hattie’s apart is its prime location on the waterfront. Guests can dine or sip cocktails while enjoying uninterrupted vistas of the water, creating a peaceful and picturesque backdrop. Whether you’re looking for a spot to watch the sunset or a place to unwind after a day at the beach, Panama Hattie’s offers a slice of paradise in St. Augustine.

10. The Bar with No Name

– Overview

For those seeking a truly unique bar experience, The Bar with No Name is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. With its mysterious concept and innovative drinks, this bar offers a one-of-a-kind adventure for the curious soul.

– Atmosphere and Ambiance

True to its name, The Bar with No Name believes in keeping things mysterious. The location of the bar is a well-guarded secret, known only to those who have been fortunate enough to stumble upon it. The unassuming entrance leads guests into an underground world filled with charm and intrigue. The dimly lit space, vintage decor, and eclectic seating arrangements create an atmosphere that is both fascinating and enigmatic.

– Menu and Drinks

The Bar with No Name prides itself on its creative and innovative drinks menu. Each drink is a unique blend of flavors and presentation, designed to surprise and delight. From smoky concoctions to whimsical creations, every sip is an adventure in itself. The expert bartenders are passionate about their craft and are more than happy to create custom drinks tailored to your preferences.

– Unique Concept

What truly sets The Bar with No Name apart is its concept. The bar invites guests to embrace the unknown and step outside their comfort zones. From the location to the drinks, every aspect of The Bar with No Name is shrouded in mystery, creating an air of excitement and anticipation. If you’re looking for an unconventional and unforgettable bar experience, The Bar with No Name is the place to be.

From historic taverns to sophisticated speakeasies, St. Augustine offers a diverse range of bars and pubs to explore. Each establishment has its own unique atmosphere and offerings, ensuring there’s something for everyone. So whether you’re in the mood for live music, craft cocktails, or stunning waterfront views, raise a glass and toast to the top 10 bars and pubs in the city of St. Augustine.