Hidden Gems: The Best Off-the-Beaten-Path Lodging In St. Augustine

Imagine stepping into a world filled with quaint charm and hidden treasures, where every corner you turn reveals a new delight. This is what awaits you in St. Augustine, a city brimming with history and old-world allure. But why settle for traditional accommodations when you can discover the best off-the-beaten-path lodging options? In this article, we will unveil the secret havens nestled away from the tourist crowds, allowing you to experience the authentic essence of St. Augustine. So pack your bags and get ready to embark on an extraordinary adventure that will leave you longing for more.

Historic Inns

The Pirate Haus Inn

If you’re looking for a truly unique and historic place to stay in St. Augustine, look no further than The Pirate Haus Inn. Located in the heart of the city’s historic district, this inn offers an immersive experience into the world of pirates. With themed rooms and a pirate-themed common area, you’ll feel like you’ve stepped back in time. The inn also offers a complimentary breakfast and is within walking distance of popular attractions and restaurants.

St. Francis Inn

For a charming and historic inn experience, consider staying at the St. Francis Inn. This bed and breakfast is located in a beautifully restored historic building and offers comfortable rooms with modern amenities. The inn also boasts a peaceful courtyard and a delicious homemade breakfast for guests to enjoy. With its convenient location near downtown St. Augustine, the St. Francis Inn is the perfect place to relax and explore the city.

The Kenwood Inn

Nestled in a quiet residential neighborhood, The Kenwood Inn offers a peaceful and historic atmosphere for your stay in St. Augustine. Built in 1865, this Victorian-era inn features beautifully appointed rooms and a welcoming ambiance. Guests can start their day with a delicious homemade breakfast and then explore the nearby attractions, including the Castillo de San Marcos and Flagler College. The Kenwood Inn is the ideal choice for those seeking a charming and historic getaway.

Quaint Bed and Breakfasts

Victorian House Bed and Breakfast

Step into the elegance of the past by staying at the Victorian House Bed and Breakfast. This charming B&B showcases the beauty and craftsmanship of the Victorian era with its intricate woodwork and period furnishings. The rooms are individually decorated and offer a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Guests can savor a delicious homemade breakfast each morning and enjoy the peaceful courtyard. Located in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, the Victorian House is the perfect retreat for a romantic getaway.

Alexander Homestead Bed and Breakfast

For a serene and intimate experience, the Alexander Homestead Bed and Breakfast is the ideal choice. This elegant 19th-century house offers beautifully appointed rooms with modern amenities and cozy fireplaces. Guests can indulge in a gourmet breakfast each morning and relax in the lush gardens surrounded by towering oak trees. The inn’s convenient location near the city’s attractions and waterfront makes it an excellent choice for exploring all that St. Augustine has to offer.

Penny Farthing Inn

If you’re a history buff or simply appreciate the charm of yesteryear, the Penny Farthing Inn is the perfect place to stay. Housed in a meticulously restored Victorian-era mansion, this inn boasts beautifully decorated rooms with antique furnishings and modern comforts. Guests can start their day with a delectable breakfast and then explore the nearby historic sites, such as the Lightner Museum and Flagler College. With its warm hospitality and elegant ambiance, the Penny Farthing Inn provides a truly memorable stay in St. Augustine.

Unique Cottages and Rentals

The Collector Luxury Inn & Gardens

For a truly unique and luxurious experience, The Collector Luxury Inn & Gardens is a must-visit. This stunning inn comprises nine historic buildings that have been meticulously restored and transformed into luxury accommodations. Each room is exquisitely designed with modern amenities and unique touches. Guests can stroll through the beautiful gardens, relax by the pool, or take a short walk to the historic district’s attractions. The Collector is a hidden gem that offers a perfect blend of history and luxury.

Casablanca Inn on the Bay

With its charming architecture and prime waterfront location, Casablanca Inn on the Bay is a popular choice among travelers seeking a unique and romantic getaway. This inn offers a selection of beautifully appointed rooms, some of which feature stunning views of Matanzas Bay. Guests can savor a delicious breakfast in the inn’s elegant dining room or relax on the bayfront veranda. Casablanca Inn’s convenient location allows guests to explore the nearby attractions, including the St. Augustine Lighthouse and Anastasia State Park.

The Cozy Coastal Cottage

For those seeking a cozy and intimate retreat, The Cozy Coastal Cottage is the perfect choice. This charming rental offers a cozy living space with a fully equipped kitchen, comfortable bedrooms, and a private patio. Situated just steps away from the beach, guests can enjoy stunning sunsets and peaceful walks along the shore. The cottage’s convenient location also allows for easy access to St. Augustine’s restaurants, shops, and attractions. The Cozy Coastal Cottage provides a home away from home and a tranquil escape by the sea.

Charming Boutique Hotels

The Bayfront Marin House

For a charming and picturesque stay in St. Augustine, The Bayfront Marin House is a top choice. This boutique hotel offers beautifully decorated rooms, some of which boast stunning views of the bay. Guests can enjoy a gourmet breakfast each morning and relax in the hotel’s serene courtyard or on the bayfront veranda. The Bayfront Marin House’s prime location near downtown St. Augustine allows guests to easily explore the city’s historic sites, shops, and restaurants.

The Flamingo Boutique Hotel

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, The Flamingo Boutique Hotel offers a unique and vibrant atmosphere. This colorful and eclectic hotel showcases the work of local artists and provides guests with a truly immersive experience. Each room is individually themed and adorned with vibrant murals and artwork. Guests can start their day with a complimentary breakfast and then venture out to explore the nearby attractions, including the Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park and Ripley’s Believe It or Not!.

Marker 8 Hotel & Marina

For those seeking a waterfront escape, Marker 8 Hotel & Marina is the perfect choice. Situated on the Intracoastal Waterway, this boutique hotel offers stunning views and a tranquil atmosphere. The spacious rooms are tastefully decorated and feature modern amenities. Guests can relax by the outdoor pool, enjoy a drink at the marina bar, or explore the nearby beaches and attractions. Marker 8 Hotel & Marina provides a serene retreat and a true taste of coastal living.

Rustic Campgrounds and Cabins

St. Augustine Beach KOA

For nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts, the St. Augustine Beach KOA offers an array of camping options. Whether you prefer tent camping, RV camping, or staying in a cozy cabin, this campground has something for everyone. Guests can enjoy a variety of amenities, including a swimming pool, fishing pond, and bike rentals. The campground’s convenient location near the beach and historic sites allows for a perfect blend of outdoor adventure and cultural exploration.

Anastasia State Park

If you’re looking to immerse yourself in nature while staying in St. Augustine, Anastasia State Park is the ideal choice. This beautiful state park offers a range of camping options, including tent and RV sites. Guests can explore the park’s pristine beaches, hike along the nature trails, or go kayaking in the estuarine marsh. With its abundant wildlife and natural beauty, Anastasia State Park provides a serene escape from the bustling city.

Compass RV Park

Located just minutes away from downtown St. Augustine, Compass RV Park offers a convenient and comfortable camping experience. The park features spacious RV sites with full hook-ups and a range of amenities, including a swimming pool, laundry facilities, and a clubhouse. Guests can easily explore the city’s attractions and then retreat to the peacefulness of the campground. Compass RV Park is the perfect choice for RV enthusiasts looking to explore St. Augustine and its surrounding areas.

Secluded Beachfront Resorts

Castillo Real, an Ascend Hotel Collection Member

For a luxurious and secluded beachfront getaway, Castillo Real is a top choice. This stunning resort offers beautifully appointed rooms with ocean views and modern amenities. Guests can relax by the outdoor pool, indulge in a spa treatment, or take a short walk to the pristine beach. The resort’s prime location also allows for easy access to St. Augustine’s historic district and its array of dining and entertainment options. Castillo Real provides a tranquil and indulgent escape by the sea.

Southern Oaks Inn

Nestled among ancient oak trees and lush gardens, Southern Oaks Inn offers a serene and secluded retreat. This charming inn features comfortable rooms with private balconies or patios, creating a peaceful oasis for guests to enjoy. Guests can relax by the outdoor pool, stroll through the gardens, or unwind in the courtyard. Southern Oaks Inn’s tranquil atmosphere, combined with its convenient location near downtown St. Augustine, makes it an ideal choice for a secluded beachfront getaway.

The Ocean Gallery Resort

If you’re looking for a secluded beachfront resort that offers a range of amenities, The Ocean Gallery Resort is the perfect choice. This expansive resort features a variety of accommodations to suit every traveler’s needs, from cozy villas to spacious condos. Guests can enjoy access to a private beach, multiple swimming pools, tennis courts, and a fitness center. The resort’s tranquil setting, combined with its array of amenities, guarantees a memorable beachfront retreat in St. Augustine.

Romantic Escapes

Bayfront Westcott House Bed & Breakfast

For a romantic escape in St. Augustine, Bayfront Westcott House Bed & Breakfast is a top choice. This charming inn offers beautifully decorated rooms with elegant furnishings and modern amenities. Guests can enjoy a gourmet breakfast in the inn’s intimate dining room or on the bayfront veranda. The inn’s prime location near the historic district allows couples to explore the city’s attractions, dine at romantic restaurants, and enjoy sunset strolls along the bayfront. Bayfront Westcott House provides a romantic and memorable escape for couples looking to reconnect.

The Old City House Inn & Restaurant

Located in a beautifully restored 19th-century building, The Old City House Inn & Restaurant offers a romantic and intimate atmosphere. The inn features elegantly appointed rooms with antique furnishings and modern comforts. Guests can savor a delicious breakfast each morning and indulge in a romantic dinner at the inn’s renowned restaurant. With its convenient location near downtown St. Augustine’s shops and attractions, The Old City House Inn & Restaurant is the perfect choice for a romantic escape.

Peace and Plenty Inn

Escape to a charming and peaceful retreat at the Peace and Plenty Inn. This historic inn offers beautifully decorated rooms with a blend of modern comforts and Old World charm. Guests can relax in the inn’s tranquil courtyard, savor a gourmet breakfast each morning, and unwind in the cozy common area. The inn’s convenient location in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district allows couples to easily explore the city’s attractions and enjoy the romance and serenity of this hidden gem.

Coastal Retreats

Vilano Beach Oceanfront Cottage

For a coastal retreat just minutes away from downtown St. Augustine, Vilano Beach Oceanfront Cottage is a perfect choice. This charming cottage offers direct access to the beach and stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean. Guests can relax on the spacious deck, take a dip in the ocean, or explore the nearby shops and restaurants. Vilano Beach Oceanfront Cottage provides a serene and idyllic escape for those seeking a coastal retreat in St. Augustine.

Anchorage Inn

Located in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, Anchorage Inn offers a convenient and comfortable coastal retreat. This charming inn features cozy rooms with modern amenities and a peaceful courtyard. Guests can start their day with a complimentary breakfast and then explore the nearby attractions, including the Castillo de San Marcos and St. George Street. Anchorage Inn’s prime location, combined with its warm hospitality, makes it an excellent choice for a coastal getaway.

Hibiscus Oceanfront Resort

Escape to paradise at the Hibiscus Oceanfront Resort. This stunning oceanfront resort offers a range of accommodations, from cozy studios to spacious condos. Guests can relax by the outdoor pool, soak up the sun on the beach, or indulge in a massage at the resort’s spa. Hibiscus Oceanfront Resort provides a tropical and luxurious coastal retreat, allowing guests to unwind and enjoy the beauty of St. Augustine’s coastline.

Historic Guesthouses

Casa de Solana Bed and Breakfast

For a stay in a historic guesthouse that exudes charm and elegance, Casa de Solana Bed and Breakfast is the perfect choice. This beautifully restored 18th-century home offers exquisitely decorated rooms with modern amenities. Guests can relax in the courtyard, savor a delicious breakfast each morning, and explore the nearby attractions, including the Lightner Museum and the Castillo de San Marcos. Casa de Solana provides a luxurious and historic experience for guests looking to immerse themselves in St. Augustine’s rich history.

Saragossa Inn

Step back in time and experience the charm of the Saragossa Inn. This historic guesthouse features beautifully appointed rooms with period furnishings and modern comforts. Guests can relax on the inn’s spacious veranda, enjoy afternoon tea in the parlor, and savor a gourmet breakfast each morning. The inn’s central location near St. George Street and other attractions makes it a perfect choice for history enthusiasts and those seeking a unique guesthouse experience.

Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast

For a stay in a historic guesthouse that offers a touch of luxury, Carriage Way Inn Bed & Breakfast is an excellent choice. This Victorian-era inn features elegantly decorated rooms, some of which boast private balconies or whirlpool tubs. Guests can start their day with a gourmet breakfast and then explore the nearby attractions, including the Lightner Museum and the St. Augustine Distillery. Carriage Way Inn provides a romantic and memorable experience for guests looking to immerse themselves in St. Augustine’s history.

Budget-Friendly Inns

Pirate’s Cove Cottages

For budget-conscious travelers looking for a unique and affordable stay in St. Augustine, Pirate’s Cove Cottages is the perfect choice. This quaint inn offers cozy cottages with modern amenities and a peaceful atmosphere. Guests can relax on the inn’s spacious deck, take a refreshing swim in the pool, or explore the nearby attractions. Pirate’s Cove Cottages provides a budget-friendly option without compromising on comfort or convenience.

Jaybird’s Inn

Located just minutes away from downtown St. Augustine, Jaybird’s Inn offers budget-friendly accommodations without sacrificing quality. This modern inn features comfortable rooms with modern amenities, including flat-screen TVs and mini-fridges. Guests can enjoy a complimentary breakfast each morning, relax by the outdoor pool, or explore the nearby attractions. Jaybird’s Inn provides affordable and convenient lodging for travelers looking to explore St. Augustine on a budget.

Sleep Inn St. Augustine

For a comfortable and affordable stay in St. Augustine, Sleep Inn St. Augustine is an excellent choice. This modern hotel offers clean and comfortable rooms with a range of amenities, including flat-screen TVs and complimentary Wi-Fi. Guests can start their day with a complimentary breakfast and then explore the city’s attractions, including the St. Augustine Lighthouse and the Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park. Sleep Inn St. Augustine provides a budget-friendly option with great value for money.