Imagine stepping back in time to a bygone era, where the cobblestone streets whisper stories of centuries past and the scent of traditional cuisine fills the air. In St. Augustine, Florida, a city known for its rich history, you can do just that. From charming colonial taverns to elegant Victorian tea rooms, this article will guide you on a culinary journey through the city’s historic dining establishments. Discover the flavors of the past and savor the unique experience of dining in a time capsule.

Must-Visit Historic Restaurants

St. Augustine, Florida is a city known for its rich history, charming architecture, and delicious cuisine. If you’re a history buff or simply love exploring unique dining experiences, you’re in for a treat. This article will guide you through the must-visit historic restaurants in St. Augustine, where you can indulge in not only mouthwatering dishes but also immerse yourself in the city’s fascinating past. From the iconic Columbia Restaurant to the cozy ambiance of The Spanish Bakery, there’s something for every food lover to enjoy in this historic city.

1. Columbia Restaurant

Overview

The Columbia Restaurant has been a beloved institution in St. Augustine since 1905. It holds the title of Florida’s oldest restaurant, proudly serving locals and tourists alike for over a century. As you step through its doors, you’ll immediately be transported to a bygone era, with Spanish-inspired decor and an atmosphere steeped in history.

Menu

The menu at the Columbia Restaurant showcases an exquisite blend of Spanish and Cuban cuisine, reflecting the city’s diverse heritage. From traditional dishes like paella and ropa vieja to their famous “1905” Salad, every bite is a flavorful journey through time. Don’t forget to try their refreshing sangria, a perfect complement to your meal.

Ambiance

The ambiance of the Columbia Restaurant is nothing short of enchanting. The charming Mediterranean-style courtyard, adorned with vibrant flowers and twinkling lights, creates a romantic setting perfect for a special occasion. Inside, you’ll find elegant dining rooms adorned with Spanish tiles and intricate woodwork, transporting you back to the Gilded Age.

2. The Tasting Room

Overview

Nestled in the heart of historic downtown St. Augustine, The Tasting Room offers a unique and intimate dining experience. Housed in a building that dates back to the 1800s, this restaurant celebrates the city’s rich history while also showcasing its contemporary culinary scene.

Menu

The Tasting Room prides itself on its ever-changing menu, highlighting the freshest local ingredients and innovative flavor combinations. Whether you’re in the mood for small plates like their famous truffle mac & cheese or a hearty entree like the Moroccan-spiced lamb chops, each dish is expertly crafted to tantalize your taste buds.

Ambiance

The Tasting Room exudes a cozy and welcoming ambiance with its exposed brick walls, soft lighting, and rustic wooden tables. The historic feel of the building is preserved through tasteful nods to the past, providing a perfect backdrop for an intimate dinner or a gathering with friends.

3. The Floridian

Overview

Located in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, The Floridian is a beloved eatery known for its Southern-inspired cuisine and commitment to using locally sourced ingredients. With a focus on sustainable practices and a menu that changes with the seasons, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Menu

At The Floridian, you can expect a menu that celebrates the flavors of the South with a modern twist. From their famous fried green tomatoes and shrimp and grits to mouthwatering sandwiches and salads, there’s something to please every palate. Finish off your meal with a slice of their famous homemade key lime pie for the perfect sweet ending.

Ambiance

The Floridian’s warm and inviting ambiance perfectly complements its menu. The quaint dining room features a mix of vintage and modern decor, with exposed brick walls and charming artwork adorning the walls. The restaurant’s commitment to sustainability is also evident through its use of reclaimed materials, giving the space a unique and environmentally conscious vibe.

4. O.C. White’s

Overview

For a taste of St. Augustine’s maritime past, look no further than O.C. White’s. Situated on the bayfront, this historic restaurant offers stunning views of the water and a menu that honors the city’s seafaring heritage.

Menu

Seafood lovers will rejoice at the menu options available at O.C. White’s. From fresh catches of the day to classic dishes like shrimp and grits and fish tacos, each bite is a flavorful homage to the region’s abundant coastal resources. Don’t forget to pair your meal with a refreshing craft beer or a specialty cocktail from their extensive bar menu.

Ambiance

O.C. White’s waterfront location is undoubtedly one of its top selling points. Whether you choose to dine on the outdoor deck and soak in the panoramic views or opt for a cozy spot inside the restaurant, you’ll be surrounded by an atmosphere that effortlessly combines nautical charm with historic elements. The restaurant’s walls are adorned with maritime artifacts and photographs, immersing you in the seafaring history of St. Augustine.

5. Milltop Tavern

Overview

If you’re in the mood for a casual dining experience with a side of live music, look no further than Milltop Tavern. Located just a stone’s throw away from the historic Castillo de San Marcos, this beloved establishment has been serving up good food, good drinks, and good times for over 30 years.

Menu

The menu at Milltop Tavern features classic American pub fare with a Southern twist. Sink your teeth into juicy burgers, mouthwatering chicken wings, or indulge in their famous fish and chips. Wash it all down with a cold beer or a refreshing cocktail, and you’re in for a delightful evening.

Ambiance

Milltop Tavern exudes a laid-back and friendly ambiance that instantly makes you feel at home. The spacious outdoor patio, complete with live music performances, offers the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal with friends. Inside, the cozy bar area welcomes you with its warm lighting and friendly staff, making it an ideal spot to unwind after a day of exploring the city.

6. The Prince of Wales

Overview

For a taste of British history in St. Augustine, The Prince of Wales is the place to be. This charming restaurant pays homage to its royal namesake while also offering a delightful menu that showcases British classics.

Menu

From traditional fish and chips to savory shepherd’s pie, The Prince of Wales serves up authentic British cuisine that will transport you straight to the streets of London. Don’t miss out on their selection of delectable desserts, like sticky toffee pudding or traditional trifle, to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Ambiance

As you step into The Prince of Wales, you’ll be greeted by a cozy and inviting atmosphere that reflects its British roots. The decor is accented with flags, family crests, and photographs of the royal family, creating a unique and immersive experience. Whether you choose to dine in the elegant indoor dining area or on the charming outdoor patio, you’ll feel like royalty throughout your visit.

7. The Columbia Cafe

Overview

The Columbia Cafe, located in the heart of the historic district, offers a more casual dining experience while still delivering the same authentic flavors as its larger counterpart, the Columbia Restaurant.

Menu

The menu at The Columbia Cafe features beloved dishes from the original restaurant, including their famous Cuban sandwich and the hearty paella. Each dish is prepared with the same attention to detail and flavorful ingredients that have made the Columbia Restaurant a St. Augustine staple.

Ambiance

The Columbia Cafe embraces a more relaxed and casual ambiance, perfect for a laid-back lunch or a quick bite to eat. The outdoor seating area allows you to enjoy the sights and sounds of St. George Street while savoring your meal. Whether you’re in the mood for a leisurely lunch or a refreshing cocktail, The Columbia Cafe offers a delightful spot to recharge during your explorations.

8. Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille

Overview

Located in a beautifully restored, turn-of-the-century building, Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille is a popular destination for both locals and visitors looking for a taste of New Orleans in St. Augustine.

Menu

Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille showcases the vibrant flavors of Cajun and Creole cuisine, offering a menu filled with favorites like jambalaya, blackened fish, and crawfish étouffée. Each dish is prepared with authentic seasonings and spices, transporting your taste buds straight to the heart of Louisiana.

Ambiance

The ambiance at Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille is a perfect blend of Southern charm and historic elegance. The building’s restored brick walls, wrought-iron accents, and antique furnishings create a warm and inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re dining in the intimate interior or enjoying the lively outdoor patio, you’ll feel the vibrant energy of New Orleans surrounding you.

9. The Spanish Bakery

Overview

Rounding out our list is The Spanish Bakery, a hidden gem tucked away in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district. This family-owned bakery has been delighting locals and visitors with its delectable pastries and authentic Spanish treats for decades.

Menu

At The Spanish Bakery, you’ll find a mouthwatering array of pastries, from flaky croissants and sweet empanadas to traditional Spanish churros dipped in rich chocolate. Pair your treats with a steaming cup of their aromatic coffee for the perfect start to your day or an afternoon pick-me-up.

Ambiance

The Spanish Bakery’s cozy and welcoming ambiance is a testament to its family-owned roots. As you enter, you’ll be greeted by the sweet scent of freshly baked goods and the warm smiles of the bakery’s friendly staff. Choose a seat by the window to enjoy the view of historic St. George Street while indulging in your sweet treats.

In conclusion, St. Augustine’s historic restaurants not only offer delectable cuisine but also provide a unique opportunity to savor the past. From the iconic Columbia Restaurant to the hidden gem of The Spanish Bakery, each establishment immerses you in the city’s rich history while offering a memorable dining experience. So, whether you’re a history enthusiast or simply seeking a delicious meal in a charming setting, these must-visit restaurants are sure to satisfy both your culinary cravings and your love for all things historic.