Historic Haunts: The Top 10 Restaurants In St. Augustine’s Oldest Buildings

Step back in time as you indulge in a culinary journey through the historic streets of St. Augustine, where some of the city’s oldest buildings have been transformed into remarkable dining establishments. From charming taverns to elegant eateries, the “Historic Haunts: The Top 10 Restaurants in St. Augustine’s Oldest Buildings” guide showcases the perfect blend of rich history and exquisite cuisine. Prepare to be captivated by the stories behind these iconic landmarks while savoring delectable dishes that bring the flavors of the past to life.

1. The Columbia Restaurant

1.1 History of the Building

Welcome to The Columbia Restaurant, one of the top choices for dining in St. Augustine’s oldest buildings! The history of this establishment dates back to 1905, making it a true gem in the city’s culinary landscape. The building that houses The Columbia Restaurant has witnessed the passing of a century and has been a witness to the rich heritage of St. Augustine.

Originally built as a bakery, the building has been transformed into a restaurant by the Hernandez family, who opened The Columbia Restaurant in 1905. Throughout the years, it has remained in the same family and is now operated by the fourth and fifth generations of the Hernandez family. This makes dining at The Columbia Restaurant not just a culinary experience but also an opportunity to step into history and connect with the roots of St. Augustine.

1.2 Menu and Dining Experience

When it comes to dining at The Columbia Restaurant, get ready for a delicious journey through the flavors of Latin cuisine. The menu at The Columbia Restaurant is a celebration of traditional Spanish and Cuban dishes, combined with modern twists and flavors. From classic paella and 1905 Salad to mouthwatering tapas and savory seafood platters, this restaurant offers a rich selection to leave your taste buds satisfied.

As you step into The Columbia Restaurant, the warm and inviting ambiance adds to the overall dining experience. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and taken care of. Whether you choose to dine in the picturesque outdoor courtyard or in one of the elegant indoor dining rooms, The Columbia Restaurant guarantees an unforgettable dining experience.

1.3 Notable Features

One of the notable features of The Columbia Restaurant is its charming courtyard. With its beautiful fountain, lush greenery, and cozy seating areas, the courtyard offers a tranquil retreat in the heart of St. Augustine. It is a perfect spot to enjoy a romantic dinner under the stars or to simply relax and savor your meal.

The restaurant also takes pride in its extensive wine list, featuring an impressive selection of Spanish and international wines. Whether you’re a wine connoisseur or simply looking for the perfect pairing with your meal, The Columbia Restaurant has something to offer.

2. Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille

2.1 History of the Building

If you’re looking for a taste of New Orleans in the heart of St. Augustine, look no further than Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille. Located in one of the city’s oldest buildings, this restaurant has a rich history that adds to its charm. The building that houses Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille has been a part of St. Augustine’s landscape since the late 1800s.

Originally built as a commercial storefront, the building has served various purposes throughout the years. From a grocery store to a bicycle shop, it has witnessed the ebb and flow of St. Augustine’s history. In 1987, the building was converted into Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille, bringing a taste of Louisiana to the shores of St. Augustine.

2.2 Menu and Dining Experience

As you step into Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille, you’ll be transported to the vibrant streets of New Orleans. The menu pays homage to the flavors of Cajun and Creole cuisine, with dishes like jambalaya, gumbo, and blackened redfish. Whether you’re a seafood lover or prefer land-based dishes, Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille has something to satisfy every palate.

The dining experience at Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille is casual and lively, reminiscent of the bustling atmosphere of New Orleans. From the lively bar area to the cozy dining booths, the restaurant offers a welcoming environment for both locals and visitors alike. The staff is known for their friendly and attentive service, making sure that every guest feels like a part of the Harry’s family.

2.3 Notable Features

One of the notable features of Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille is its outdoor patio. With its colorful accents, comfortable seating, and lively atmosphere, the patio is a popular spot for enjoying a meal or a refreshing drink. It’s the perfect place to soak up the Florida sun while savoring the flavors of New Orleans.

The restaurant also offers an impressive selection of craft beers and signature cocktails. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Hurricane or a refreshing mojito, Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille has a drink to quench your thirst and complement your meal.

3. The Floridian

3.1 History of the Building

Step inside The Floridian and you’ll be transported to a bygone era. Housed in a historic building that dates back to the late 1800s, this restaurant is a testament to the enduring charm of St. Augustine. The building that houses The Floridian has seen many changes over the years, but its historic character remains intact.

Originally constructed as a boarding house, the building has served as a hotel, a grocery store, and even a bakery in its long history. In 2010, it was transformed into The Floridian, offering a unique dining experience that combines Southern comfort food with a modern twist.

3.2 Menu and Dining Experience

The menu at The Floridian showcases the best of Southern cuisine, with a focus on locally-sourced ingredients and flavors. From crispy fried chicken and shrimp and grits to collard greens and buttermilk biscuits, the dishes are a celebration of Southern comfort food at its finest. The chefs at The Floridian put their own spin on traditional recipes, adding innovative touches that elevate each dish.

The dining experience at The Floridian is relaxed and laid-back. The restaurant features a charming interior with exposed brick walls, vintage decorations, and cozy booths that create a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The staff is known for their warm hospitality, making sure that every guest feels right at home.

3.3 Notable Features

One of the notable features of The Floridian is its commitment to sustainability and supporting local farmers. The restaurant strives to source its ingredients from local farmers and artisans, ensuring that each dish is fresh, flavorful, and supports the community. The Floridian also offers vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, making it a great choice for diners with dietary restrictions.

In addition to its delicious food, The Floridian is also known for its craft beer selection. The restaurant offers a variety of local and regional craft beers, allowing guests to pair their meal with the perfect brew.

(Continued in part 2)