Gourmet Getaway: 10 Fine Dining Restaurants In St. Augustine

Are you a food lover searching for the perfect dining experience in St. Augustine? Look no further! In this article, we will take you on a mouth-watering journey through the top 10 fine dining restaurants in this charming city. From elegant waterfront establishments to cozy hidden gems, these culinary havens offer exquisite menus and impeccable service that will leave you craving for more. So, grab your napkin and prepare to indulge in a gourmet getaway like no other. Bon appétit!

Oceanfront Dining

The Reef

Located right on the oceanfront, The Reef offers a truly magical dining experience with breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean. As you indulge in their delectable menu, the sound of crashing waves sets the perfect soundtrack for a memorable meal. The Reef specializes in fresh seafood, expertly prepared by their talented chefs. From succulent shrimp scampi to perfectly grilled fish, every bite is a celebration of coastal flavors. The restaurant’s warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with the stunning ocean views, make it an ideal destination for a romantic date night or a special occasion with loved ones.

Saltwater Cowboys

For a true taste of the Florida coast, head over to Saltwater Cowboys. This rustic oceanfront restaurant embraces the coastal lifestyle and offers a laid-back dining experience that is second to none. From their signature dish, the Cowboy Ribeye, to their mouthwatering seafood platters, Saltwater Cowboys takes pride in delivering top-notch quality and flavor. Whether you choose to dine indoors or soak up the sun on their outdoor patio, you’ll feel like a true cowboy, enjoying a delicious meal with the ocean as your backdrop.

Caps on the Water

If you’re looking for a waterfront dining experience that perfectly blends ambiance, flavor, and creativity, look no further than Caps on the Water. This hidden gem is nestled along the Intracoastal Waterway and offers stunning panoramic views of the surrounding marshes. Their menu boasts a variety of fresh seafood options, from crispy fried oysters to perfectly seared scallops. But what truly sets Caps on the Water apart is their innovative twists on classic dishes, like their famous shrimp and grits with Creole sauce. With its charming atmosphere and mouthwatering cuisine, Caps on the Water is a must-visit for any food enthusiast.

Spanish Cuisine

Columbia Restaurant

Step into a world of Spanish flavors at the iconic Columbia Restaurant. This family-owned establishment has been serving authentic Spanish cuisine since 1905, making it Florida’s oldest restaurant. The Columbia Restaurant in St. Augustine carries on this rich culinary tradition, offering an extensive menu that feature classic dishes like paella, ropa vieja, and Cuban sandwiches. The vibrant and lively atmosphere, complete with flamenco dancers and live music, transports you directly to Spain, making for an unforgettable dining experience.

Michael’s Tasting Room

For an intimate and refined dining experience, make your way to Michael’s Tasting Room. This cozy restaurant is all about providing guests with an elevated Spanish culinary journey. Their menu showcases a careful selection of tapas, such as the popular bacon-wrapped dates and tender Spanish-style pork ribs. Pair your meal with a glass of quality Spanish wine, handpicked by their knowledgeable sommelier. The attentive staff and charming ambiance create the perfect backdrop for a memorable evening of indulgence.

Costa Brava

Nestled within a charming Mediterranean-style hotel, Costa Brava is the epitome of sophistication and elegance. With its white tablecloths, soft lighting, and impeccable service, this restaurant sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The menu at Costa Brava showcases the best of Spanish cuisine, with dishes like seafood paella and grilled Spanish octopus stealing the show. Each bite is a tantalizing journey through the flavors of Spain, perfectly complemented by an extensive list of Spanish wines. For those seeking a refined and luxurious culinary experience, Costa Brava is the ultimate destination.

Seafood Specialties

Catch 27

Advocating for sustainable seafood practices, Catch 27 prides itself on serving fresh, locally sourced ingredients that celebrate the bounty of the ocean. This cozy little eatery offers a menu focused on seafood delicacies that are expertly prepared with a modern twist. From their mouthwatering blackened fish tacos to their legendary shrimp and grits, every dish is bursting with flavor. The intimate and relaxed atmosphere, combined with the restaurant’s dedication to environmentally conscious dining, make Catch 27 a favorite among seafood enthusiasts.

O’Steen’s Restaurant

A St. Augustine institution since 1965, O’Steen’s Restaurant has been delighting locals and visitors alike with their exceptional seafood dishes. Known for their famous shrimp, O’Steen’s serves up platters of perfectly breaded and fried shrimp that will have you coming back for more. The restaurant’s warm and welcoming atmosphere, complete with checkered tablecloths and friendly staff, adds to the overall charm of this beloved seafood spot. Don’t forget to order their homemade tartar sauce for an extra burst of flavor!

Collage Restaurant

For a fine dining experience that beautifully combines seafood with global flavors, Collage Restaurant is a must-visit. This elegant establishment offers a diverse menu that showcases the culinary expertise of their chefs. From the delicate flavors of their house-cured salmon to the rich and buttery lobster tail, Collage takes seafood to another level. The attention to detail, both in the presentation and taste of each dish, is truly remarkable. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving an unforgettable meal, Collage Restaurant delivers a dining experience to remember.

Eclectic Flavors

The Floridian

If you’re in the mood for a uniquely Floridian dining experience, The Floridian will not disappoint. This eclectic restaurant embraces the vibrant flavors of Florida, with a menu that pays homage to the state’s rich culinary heritage. Offering a range of dishes that incorporate locally sourced ingredients, The Floridian takes classic Southern comfort foods and elevates them with creative twists. From their Florida cornbread stack to their famous fried green tomatoes, every dish is a celebration of the Sunshine State’s diverse flavors.

Preserved Restaurant

Combining elements of Southern comfort food with international influences, Preserved Restaurant offers a dining experience that is both familiar and adventurous. This charming establishment boasts a menu that focuses on utilizing fresh, seasonal ingredients to create bold and innovative dishes. From their tender beef short ribs to their delicate crab cakes, each plate at Preserved is a work of art. The cozy and intimate ambiance, complete with exposed brick walls and rustic decor, adds to the overall charm of this unique culinary destination.

Raintree Restaurant

Tucked away in a historic Victorian house, Raintree Restaurant offers a dining experience that is as enchanting as it is delicious. The restaurant’s menu features an eclectic fusion of flavors, incorporating influences from around the world. From their tender filet mignon to their delectable seafood dishes, each item on the menu at Raintree Restaurant is expertly prepared and beautifully presented. The serene garden patio is the perfect spot to enjoy your meal, surrounded by lush greenery and the subtle sounds of nature.

Italian Delights

La Pentola

For an authentic taste of Italy in the heart of St. Augustine, look no further than La Pentola. This charming Italian eatery is known for its warm hospitality and mouthwatering Italian cuisine. From their traditional Neapolitan pizza to their homemade pasta dishes, La Pentola redefines Italian comfort food. The cozy and intimate atmosphere, complete with checkered tablecloths and vintage photographs, adds to the overall charm of this hidden gem. Pair your meal with a glass of Italian wine and indulge in the flavors of Italy.

Pizzalley’s Chianti Room

A favorite among locals and visitors alike, Pizzalley’s Chianti Room is the place to go for delicious Italian fare in a fun and friendly atmosphere. With its lively and vibrant ambiance, this restaurant creates the perfect setting to enjoy classic Italian dishes. From their flavorful wood-fired pizzas to their hearty lasagna, every bite at Pizzalley’s is a burst of authentic Italian flavors. Don’t forget to save room for dessert, as their homemade tiramisu is simply divine.

Nonna’s Trattoria

Nestled in the heart of St. Augustine’s historic district, Nonna’s Trattoria offers a cozy and romantic dining experience that transports you directly to Italy. The restaurant’s menu showcases traditional Italian dishes, made with love and passion. From their mouthwatering eggplant parmesan to their tender veal piccata, every dish at Nonna’s Trattoria is a true delight. The warm and welcoming atmosphere, complete with candles and soft Italian music, creates the perfect backdrop for a romantic evening or a gathering with friends.